for reviewers
At archipelagos we are working to build a community of reviewers and contributors so to sustain and enrich our collective Caribbeanist scholarship. If you would like to join our team of reviewers—to help us review articles and digital projects—please contact us at archipelagosjournal@gmail.com.
Table of Contents
Review Guidelines by Submission Type
archipelagos accepts submissions across several valences—critical essays, process essays, digital project dialogues, and digital project reviews. Our review process for digital projects is crafted in accordance with the DHCommons model, with some additions and revisions. Once peer review is completed, projects are “launched” via a dedicated page on the archipelagos platform. This landing page features a brief description of and link to the project, along with excerpts of audio, visual, and other multimedia elements. This page also provides a link to (a curated version of) the dialogue between site authors and peer reviewers. We ask that digital projects submitted for review provide a minimum of two years of post-beta support, and we encourage reviewers to remain attentive to how conscious a project team is of its own life cycle. For submission requirements and review timelines specific to each valence, see the corresponding section on our About page.
Critical Essays
Our reviewers are expected to maintain the highest academic standards in the review of scholarly articles for publication in archipelagos.
Please answer the following questions with as much elaboration as you feel the author and/or editors may need.
- Is the submission coherent, well structured and lucidly presented?
- Since many of our articles are media-rich—linking prose arguments rhetorically to visuals—we ask our reviewers also to provide feedback on the figures, images, and interactives used in articles. If the submission includes visual materials, how effectively integrated are these materials into the argument? Are there too many images? Too few?
- Does the submission make a new and significant contribution that has relevance to a Caribbean platform of criticism?
- Does the submission exhibit the kind of critical rethinking that is consistent with the archipelagos project?
- Does the submission display a knowledge of existing literature on the subject and contribute to its critical examination?
- We are particularly interested in submissions that provide a clear sense of what is at stake in their conceptual and analytical interventions. Do you recommend this submission for acceptance? For acceptance with revision? For rejection?
Process Essays
Please answer the following questions with as much elaboration as you feel the author and/or editors may need.
-
Is the submission coherent, well structured, and lucidly presented?
-
We ask reviewers to carefully weigh the de facto or possible intellectual contribution of the project described. Reviewers should consider the nature of that contribution appropriate to the current stage of the project’s development and consider early signs of process-derived knowledge; the project’s relationship to existing literature/projects; and/or early conversations in the literature about the project (where appropriate).
- Are the methods used in the project appropriate to the research questions it poses?
- Do the project’s methods contribute to digital scholarship in general, and if so, do the authors address how?
-
We ask reviewers to be conscious of the labor that goes into the development of a digital project. archipelagos encourages the crediting of work where credit is due and the acknowledgment of the scholarly and interpretative work involved in data curation, design, and the engineering of digital projects. Reviewers should ask the following questions of a project:
- Do the authors address how contributor attribution is handled?
- Are the labor conditions under which the project was (or is being) produced made evident?
- Does the work cite its (digital scholarship) precedents and data sources appropriately?
-
When considering the life cycle of a digital scholarship project, reviewers should not consider preservation in terms of indefinite periods of time. We encourage authors to be realistic about the plausible rate of decay of their projects and to have plans in place to manage the obsolescence of the technologies they use. We encourage our reviewers, therefore, to look for signs that the project team has considered the project’s future. Possible questions are:
- What standards have been used and why?
- How is the project managing its rate of decay?
- Is the level of complexity of the project appropriate for its socio-technical or institutional context?
-
Since many of our articles are media-rich—linking prose arguments rhetorically to visuals—we ask our reviewers also to provide feedback on the figures, images, and interactives used in articles. If the submission includes visual materials, how effectively integrated are these materials into the argument? Are there too many images? Too few?
-
Does the submission exhibit the kind of critical rethinking that is consistent with the archipelagos project?
-
We are particularly interested in submissions that provide a clear sense of what is at stake in their conceptual and analytical interventions. Do you recommend this submission for acceptance? For acceptance with revision? For rejection?
Digital Project Dialogues
Please answer the following questions with as much elaboration as you feel the author and/or editors may need.
-
We ask reviewers to carefully weigh the de facto or possible intellectual contribution of the project. Reviewers should consider the nature of that contribution appropriate to the current stage of the project’s development and consider early signs of process-derived knowledge; the project’s relationship to existing literature/projects; and/or early conversations in the literature about the project (where appropriate).
- Will the project frame new conversations in the relevant subject area?
- Are the methods used in the project appropriate to the research questions it poses?
- Do the project’s methods contribute to digital scholarship in general, and if so, how?
-
We ask reviewers to be conscious of the labor that goes into the development of a digital project. Digital projects generally depend on more distributed collaboration than monographs or articles. archipelagos encourages the crediting of work where credit is due and the acknowledgment of the scholarly and interpretative work involved in data curation, design, and the engineering of digital projects. Reviewers should ask the following questions of a project:
- Does the project credit its contributors openly and fairly?
- Are the labor conditions under which the project was produced made evident?
- Does the work cite its (digital scholarship) precedents and data sources appropriately?
-
Although design constitutes a separate category of review, we ask reviewers to understand design in terms of its relationship to the purported intellectual contribution of a given project. For archipelagos, design includes back-end architecture, workflow, and front-end interface design. We ask reviewers to consider the overall temporal and technical structure of a project and how this structure relates to the goals of the project. A reviewer may ask questions like:
- How do effort and resources used in the project match its import?
- How do the graphic and UX design elements of the front end contribute to the goals of the intellectual contribution? (When considering the public-facing design, reviewers should not place undue weight on “ease of use” or “glossy design” but rather consider whether the project’s features fit the intellectual mission of the project and the resources the project’s team had available to them.)
- How does the back-end architecture hinder or move forward the contribution of the project and perhaps link it to existing digital scholarship projects?
-
When considering the life cycle of a digital scholarship project, reviewers should not consider preservation in terms of indefinite periods of time. We encourage authors to be realistic about the plausible rate of decay of their projects and to have plans in place to manage the obsolescence of the technologies they use. We encourage our reviewers, therefore, to look for signs that the project team has considered the project’s future. Possible questions are:
- What standards have been used and why?
- How robust is the documentation on the project? Could the project be decomposed and recomposed based on this documentation?
- How is the project managing its rate of decay?
- Is the level of complexity of the project appropriate for its socio-technical or institutional context?
-
Does the submission exhibit the kind of critical rethinking that is consistent with the archipelagos project?
-
We are particularly interested in submissions that provide a clear sense of what is at stake in their conceptual and analytical interventions. Do you recommend this submission for acceptance? For acceptance with revision? For rejection?
Digital Project Reviews
Please answer the following questions with as much elaboration as you feel the author and/or editors may need when writing about a project.
-
Is the submission coherent, well structured, and lucidly presented?
-
We ask reviewers to carefully weigh the de facto or possible intellectual contribution of the project. Reviewers should consider the nature of that contribution appropriate to the current stage of the project’s development and consider early signs of process-derived knowledge; the project’s relationship to existing literature/projects; and/or early conversations in the literature about the project (where appropriate).
- Will the project frame new conversations in the relevant subject area?
- Are the methods used in the project appropriate to the research questions it poses?
- Do the project’s methods contribute to digital scholarship in general, and if so, how?
-
We ask reviewers to be conscious of the labor that goes into the development of a digital project. Digital projects generally depend on more distributed collaboration than monographs or articles. archipelagos encourages the crediting of work where credit is due and the acknowledgment of the scholarly and interpretative work involved in data curation, design, and the engineering of digital projects. Reviewers should ask the following questions of a project:
- Does the project credit its contributors openly and fairly?
- Are the labor conditions under which the project was produced made evident?
- Does the work cite its (digital scholarship) precedents and data sources appropriately?
-
When considering the life cycle of a digital scholarship project, reviewers should not consider preservation in terms of indefinite periods of time. Is the project under review realistic about the plausible rate of decay of their projects and to have plans in place to manage the obsolescence of the technologies they use? We encourage our reviewers, therefore, to look for signs that the project team has considered the project’s future. Possible questions are:
- What standards have been used and why?
- How robust is the documentation on the project? Could the project be decomposed and recomposed based on this documentation?
- How is the project managing its rate of decay?
- Is the level of complexity of the project appropriate for its sociotechnical or institutional context?
-
Does the project reviewed exhibit the kind of critical rethinking that is consistent with the archipelagos project? We are particularly interested in reviews of projects that provide a clear sense of what is at stake in their conceptual and analytical interventions.
